The Obstruction Rule

The latest NRL news, intelligent rugby league analysis, and innovative NRL statistics

The Obstruction Rule - Rugby league analysis, news, and VOA NRL statistics
  • VOA Ratings
    • VOA Explained
  • Features
    • Tips
    • Editorials
    • History
    • The Month In Review
    • The Greatest Game Of All
    • Culture
  • What Have We Learned
  • Teams
    • Brisbane Broncos News
    • Canberra Raiders News
    • Canterbury Bulldogs News
    • Cronulla Sharks News
    • Gold Coast Titans News
    • Manly Sea Eagles News
    • Melbourne Storm News
    • New Zealand Warriors News
    • Newcastle Knights News
    • North Queensland Cowboys News
    • Parramatta Eels News
    • Penrith Panthers News
    • South Sydney Rabbitohs News
    • St George Illawarra Dragons News
    • Sydney Roosters News
    • Wests Tigers News
  • Tips
  • About

Meninga suggests change to Test payments to benefit Tier 2 nations

March 20, 2018, 4:10 pm By Joel 1 Comment

For a start, we hate the term ‘Tier 2 nation’ in the first place (could Australia, New Zealand and England be any more condescending?) but given the tier structure’s entanglement in international eligibility, we don’t really have a choice. One day, however, we hope that won’t be the case.

And that day may come that little bit sooner, if Kangaroos coach Mal Meninga has anything to do with it. According to SMH, Meninga has suggested a radical change to Test payments, in order to encourage players to stick with the so-called ‘Tier 2 nations’.

Specifically, Meninga has put forward the idea that Australia – and, necessarily, New Zealand and England – give up their rich match payments, and have them placed into a pool, where they’d then be awarded to participants based on results.

Should New Zealand and England agree, this would be a giant step in the right direction, as it would give a team like Tonga, for example, the opportunity to not only match, but potentially out-earn a ‘Tier 1’ team like New Zealand, if they were to beat them – as they did at last year’s Rugby League World Cup.

We love the idea, but would argue it actually doesn’t go far enough. Making the payments performance-related isn’t a huge risk for the Kangaroos, who have relatively little decent competition as it is. Given their half-century long dominance, Australia would no doubt be understandably confident of winning the money back.

In a perfect world, the NRL would fund equal Test payments for all the Southern Hemisphere teams, at whatever number the game can afford. As the only major professional competition in the region, the NRL inevitably pillages the Pacific Islands of their best talent, and as a result has a moral obligation to fund those nations, as the de facto guardian for the sport in the Southern Hemisphere (likewise the RFL in the Northern Hemisphere).

The fact that the NRL hasn’t done so already is disappointing, and when they’ve then turned the pay disparity into an opportunity to poach home-grown Pacific talent like Semi Radradra and Akuila Uate on ‘residency’ grounds, it’s down-right offensive (think about it for a moment; quite literally every single top-flight Pacific Island player will inevitably become Australian or New Zealander on residency, by virtue of the fact that they’re the only two places in the region that you can play professional rugby league).

You could (and we do) argue that the ‘Tier 1’ nations shouldn’t be picking dual-eligible players in the first place, in order to encourage competitive balance; but we understand that that’s likely a bridge too far (at least at the moment).

In the meantime, addressing the pay disparity will go a long way to correcting the problem, by removing the financial sacrifices players have to make in opting for their country of heritage.

Meninga’s suggestion isn’t perfect, but it’s a huge leap forward.

Share:

Related NRL News & Posts:

  • International calendar confirmed
  • The Weekend Wrap: 15/7/18
  • Demetriou tipped for Kiwis job
  • NZRL’s “damning review” to be released Friday
  • NZRL CEO resigns

Filed Under: Editorials, NRL Features & Analysis, NRL News and Rumours Tagged With: Australia Kangaroos, Mal Meninga, New Zealand Kiwis

Comments

  1. Grant Wilson says

    May 17, 2018, 11:26 am at 11:26 am

    It is a completely fake competition. These nationals have no real comp and they simply fill there whole teams ( PNG perhaps excluded) with Australians and New Zealanders. We can all feel good about it but what doesn’t make me fell good is that these Australians really don’t like us – and it borderline racism against what they must think of us white Aussies – and perhaps Kiwis – because all they want to do is play for a Country they -or their Parents, or their Grand-parents – or even Great-grandparents left to come to our great country whole welcomes them. It makes me wonder why they are not point or even hate Australia ( and NZ)

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As featured on NewsNow: NRL news
NRL News 24/7

Latest Features

NRL Tips – 2019 Grand Final

TOR in 2019

Rabbitohs Need To Put Difficult Pre-Season Behind Them

End of an Era: No sunset ride for Thurston

The Month In Review: July ’18

The Month In Review: June ’18

The Month In Review: May ’18

Numbers Do Lie: Why Woods isn’t better than Campbell-Gillard (Or, why Michael Chammas should stick to reporting, and leave statistics to people who actually understand them)

The Month In Review: April ’18

The Month In Review: March ’18

More Features

Latest NRL Previews

NRL Tips – Week 7, 2021

NRL Tips – Week 6, 2021

NRL Tips – Week 5, 2021

NRL Tips – Week 4, 2021

NRL Tips – Week 3, 2021

More Tips & Previews

Email Updates

Sign up for The Obstruction Rule email updates and receive FREE VOA-based NRL line-betting tips for each round for the rest of 2018!




Top 5 NRL Offense VOA

Melbourne45.15%
Penrith33.26%
Sydney32.61%
South Sydney25.46%
Parramatta18.08%

Top 5 NRL Defense VOA

Penrith-58.14%
Melbourne-38.21%
South Sydney-36.99%
Sydney-24.30%
Parramatta-15.86%

Full sortable NRL VOA ratings

LIVE NRL SCORES

Friends of TOR

NRL Universe

Contact Us

Email Facebook Twitter Instagram

Search

This is an unofficial and independent source of NRL news and information not affiliated with any team(s) or the National Rugby League (NRL).

Copyright © 2021 · Metro Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

The Obstruction Rule - The latest NRL news, rumours, previews and analysis